Book picks similar to
Born to be Witchy by A.J. Macey


reverse-harem
fantasy
paranormal
witches

Wrecked


Crea Reitan - 2021
    My previous foster families – twelve, to be exact – said I was a menace. A terror. My teachers claim I am truly disturbed. My pediatricians said I suffered from an imbalance due to something my mother did during my gestation. My psychiatrists and counselors reported that I was a psychopath.The last are the ones that got it right.But you see, though I was probably born this way – my childhood is plenty of evidence to the affirmation of such a claim – I’ve changed over the years. I became obsessed with Xan when we were kids, the day she told my foster family that I would never hurt her. That she trusted me. Unwise of her, perhaps, for at that time, I was indifferent to her. Later I fell in love with her. Xan, Issy, and Wade. They were all mine. Issy and Wade had come around but Xan… she didn’t know.It didn’t change the fact that she was mine. It simply meant that I needed to get rid of the obstacle in my way. The real thing you ought to know is that, right now, I’m on a mission to burn everyone who has ever wrecked our girl. I don’t mean that figuratively. I’m going to light their sorry asses on fire and watched them die slow, agonizing deaths. I’m going to let their screams heal the wounds they inflicted on Xan and satisfy my need to punish anyone who’s ever hurt my girl.For her, we will burn them all.**This is a new adult, reverse harem, dark romance novel with a ‘why choose’ ending, meaning the main character gets a happily ever after with more than one man. It contains past emotional abuse, torture, molestation, explicit sex scenes, blood, murder. This is a MMFM book (there is some MM and MMF in here, too).

The Lost and the Hunted


Grace McGinty - 2021
    No, it was the fear. The fear of being captured and becoming another statistic, another underground prize. When an unintentional rescue results in some accidental consequences, Celeste knows that the sunny-natured Reese will have her back. However, she didn’t plan on his best friends being quite so hostile, or the fact that Reese was one of the youngest billionaires in the US. His friends look at her and see just another gold digger; one they want gone by any means necessary. Fine, she hadn’t planned on staying anyway, but while she was here, she was happy to play cat and mouse with Lincoln, the jacked-up bodyguard and Vincent, the way too pretty rockstar. Because her snow leopard? She wanted to roll around on them like they were catnip and she’d never been great at self-denial. But death still waits in the shadows for its prize, and this time, there will be no accidental savior coming to her rescue. This is a Reverse Harem novel, meaning Celeste doesn't have to choose between her guys. There is also steamy scenes, M/M action and swearing.

Crossed Souls


Heather Ashley - 2021
    If it wasn’t for my self-appointed guardians, I wouldn’t have even made it this far.They may not have asked for this either, but the whole town’s afraid of Knox, Hiro’s suspicious of everything (including me), Crew’s power is as legendary as mine, and Ever is our leader… who’s keeping a secret of his own.With the four of them by my side, I might just stand a chance of getting out of this alive.See, Soul Magic has been dead for centuries. It shouldn’t exist anymore, long forgotten like a fairy tale warped and twisted in time.Except it does exist—in me.My name is Willa Toussaint and I’m the last Soul Mage alive. Whether I’m ready or not, my enemies are coming to steal my birthright, black spellwork thickens the air, and I’ve never been more terrified.There’s only one thing left to do—survive.PLEASE NOTE: The heroine in this story will end up with more than one love interest and will never choose between them. This is book one in a five book series and will end on a cliffhanger.

Illusion of Escape


Lana Kole - 2018
    Focused on helping kids the system forgets, she is unaware of the powers she harbors deep in her soul. The intensity of her dreams waver between a nightmare and a true confidant. Imagine her surprise when she realizes her dreams might be more than they seem, she suddenly has crazy magic powers, and three strange men crash a too good to be true second date for help finding their long-lost friend. Loyalty means you don’t quit… Closer than brothers, Kaiser, Walker, Remington and Levi are not one without the others. Since Walker’s disappearance three years prior, they have not been the same. Driven to find their lost comrade, they are not above breaking any laws, be they magekynd or human. When a fluke encounter alerts them to Mori’s potential, they cannot ignore their instincts. Can they earn Mori’s trust after kidnapping her or will she walk away from the crazy world she’s been thrust into and the men who need her help? *87,953 word count full length first book in a series of three. *This is a Reverse Harem Paranormal Romance and is not suited for those under the age of 18.

Howl and the Moon


Rae Foxx - 2019
     Their plan at a heat filled night erupts when an unexpected visitor stops by with a debt to pay. Will Ivy's night be more of a trick, or a treat. Howl and the Moon is a 40k word Novella that lives in the world of Bloodwood Academy. This stand alone story features Ivy and her guys in her first Halloween at school. There's magic, haunts, and so much heat that it might melt your kindle!

Hexed, Vexed, and Undersexed: Trials of a Salem Witch


M.J. Marstens - 2020
    . .I learned that reality tv isn’t real.To undo the curse that was placed on my family centuries ago, I must compete in the human game show called Modern Day Witch Hunt.The prize: Mother Shipton’s grimoire.The irony: only a spell from its pages can reverse the hex.The stakes: my family will lose all their magical ability without that spell.All I need is a new hairstyle, a new name, and a complete personality change—easy, right?Throw in a fake-ass broom and a black cat with a little magic, and I have this competition in the bag.Nothing is going to stop me from winning back my family’s long-lost grimoire.Nothing. . .Except maybe the asshole whose family hexed mine.WARNING: This is a reverse harem comedy starring a witch-bitch turned hippie, a sexy 'on-screen' coach, one arch rival with a wand up his ass, a few surprises, and plenty of spells waiting to go wrong.

Hexed and Vexed


Rebecca Royce - 2013
    When Enforcers whisk her away from her sister’s wedding, she finds herself in the company of Lawson Abramowitz—the hottest, nicest witch she’s ever met. Weirder still—he seems interested in her. So between running her shop, placating her socially minded mother, her match-making best friend, and a magical world turned upside down, Ava will face all sorts of challenges. Can the worst witch ever actually be the savior the witching world needs?

Demon Stalked


Ann Denton - 2021
    But are we going to let our mate tell us to take a hike? Hell no.We're going to woo the shit out of this human girl, get her to go to this winter dance, and make all of her dreams come true. Because that's what demons do...right? This is 1.5 of the Darkest Flames series. It should be read after Demon Kissed and before Demon Loved. This continues a reverse harem romance, strong language, and sexual situations.

Corviticus University


J.E. Cluney - 2019
    And it’s going to be a struggle to stick to my personal rules of no sexual relationships with them. They’re all so tempting, sweet, and funny. Well, except for one.Yep, definitely hard.And with their help, I’ll learn to manage my mischief magic. No more flying, honking vibrators for me.But questions rise when more powers surface for me, and it’s obvious I’m not just your average pixie halfling.Can we find answers together? And can I stick to my personal rules of friends only?Please note this is a mature reverse harem, slow/medium burn. Intended for audiences 18+

Witch's Three


Jewel Killian - 2020
    Jeez.Delilah's got more magic than anyone. Ever. So, naturally the government wants it, sending a team of three why-are-they-soooo-flippin'-hot guys after her. One of whom, just so happens to be her familiar. Her human familiar -- that hasn't happened in, well, ever. But the government isn't alone in wanting a piece of Del's power. Something else is after her. Something dark and twisted. Something which no one believes exists. How could it?Witch's Three is a medium-burn FMMM RH with a hunky unicorn shifter, a dead sexy seer, and a grumbly, broody gargoyle and Delilah will never, ever have to choose between them.

Magic Swap


Sadie Moss - 2019
    Sounds like the start of a joke, but nope...It's my life.After one too many kamikazes on my twenty-first birthday, I've made a few interesting discoveries.First of all... magic is real.Secondly... there's a whole supernatural dimension that exists parallel to ours.Thirdly... I've somehow gotten stuck in that dimension.FML.There are about a billion things wrong with this picture, including the fact that I don't actually have any magic. Everyone here thinks I do though. They also think I'm a witch named Roxie, the star student at Radcliffe Magical Academy.Ummm. Nope. Not me. Sorry.I don't know where the hell the real Roxie is, or how I'm supposed to get back home, but I'm determined to find out.Unfortunately, I keep getting distracted by three hot-as-hell warlocks I can't seem to avoid. Cross, a snarky bad boy who pushes all my buttons, Theo, an incorrigible flirt with a devastating accent, and Kasian, a teacher's assistant who's totally off limits.Even though I'm drawn to all three of them, I'm not sure I should trust them.Because if anybody finds out I don't belong here...I'm screwed.Magic Swap is the first book in the Hidden World Academy series, a fast-burn reverse harem story about a sassy human who's out of her depth and the three men who fall in love with her.

Chasing Her Tail


Katie Allen - 2009
    So it’s a bit of a shock when she’s bitten by a were-puppy and transformed into a dog. As if peeing outside, excessive furriness and squirrel-chasing urges aren’t enough, it seems as if everyone is after Bridget—including a billionaire with an unhealthy interest in the paranormal, and Micah, the smoking-hot uncle of her were-puppy student. When she takes refuge with Hammer, a kind stranger who has the body of a god and feeds her hamburgers, Bridget thinks she’s safe. Micah’s hot on her trail, however, and the crazy billionaire isn’t about to let a were-dog slip through his fingers. Meanwhile, Hammer is determined to discover the truth about the mysterious woman who visits his bedroom at night—wearing nothing but a black leather collar. Chasing Her Tail features a cameo by Hammer’s friends Harry, Beth and Ky. Get to know the trio more…intimately…in Katie Allen’s One-Two Punch.

Room Twenty: Her Mountain Men Masters (Club Sin)


Shae Sullivan - 2021
    The day when all the pain and loss of the last five years would disappear, and I’d finally get a real chance to collect my small inheritance and honor my parents.But I should’ve known that my greedy, abusive uncle would never let me go.Not only has he emptied my accounts, but now he’s trying to marry me off to a man almost three times my age. There’s only one reason a man like him wants a girl like me...and it isn’t good.When we show up at Club Sin for our introduction, I’m immediately looking for a way out. And I find it…. in Room Twenty, and the arms of a trio of rugged, mountain men who are old enough to be my daddies.This is totally irrational, and the last thing I should be doing is getting hot and heavy with strangers right now, but I know this might be my last chance for pleasure—and I’m grasping at it.This entire situation is wrong and taboo, and yet the further down the rabbit whole we go, the more I want. But I know it’s only a matter of time before my uncle and that man find me, and everything gets taken away from me…again. *This is a forbidden age gap reverse harem romance with an HEA****Fantasies are meant to come true and the men of Club Sin will see to your every kinky desire. This November, 22 of your favorite steamy romance authors take you inside Club Sin, a forbidden place where you’ll find love and pleasure with multiple hot men in these Reverse Harem novellas. Can you handle the heat?22 rooms, 22 fantasies…Which door will you step through?

Goddess of Pain


Katie May - 2020
    And the people who tried to hurt my family?They'll suffer for what they've done.This is a paranormal reverse harem romance stand-alone and part of the shared Blood Moon Rising world. This book contains psychotic alpha males who will do anything for their woman. It also contains strong language, violence, and sexual situations. Reader's discretion is advised. Be prepared to meet a take-no-prisoners Goddess and her killer men.

First Addition


Kelsey Soliz - 2020
    What I had been hiding.Now, my father is making me attend the school he headmasters, a stuck-up elite academy that will never take a bodysmith like me seriously.Fate may have cursed me with six mate spots to fill, but that doesn't mean I need to tell everyone my true purpose for being at the academy.If I can survive the other petty circulators at the school that think they're queen bee, and hide my own status from everyone, I just might be able to find the six men that I don't really want.They might think I'm inconsequential, but I'm determined to carve out my own happiness, no matter what it takes.