Book picks similar to
Secrets and Sins by Elle Middaugh


rh
reverse-harem
paranormal
paranormal-romance

Crossed Souls


Heather Ashley - 2021
    If it wasn’t for my self-appointed guardians, I wouldn’t have even made it this far.They may not have asked for this either, but the whole town’s afraid of Knox, Hiro’s suspicious of everything (including me), Crew’s power is as legendary as mine, and Ever is our leader… who’s keeping a secret of his own.With the four of them by my side, I might just stand a chance of getting out of this alive.See, Soul Magic has been dead for centuries. It shouldn’t exist anymore, long forgotten like a fairy tale warped and twisted in time.Except it does exist—in me.My name is Willa Toussaint and I’m the last Soul Mage alive. Whether I’m ready or not, my enemies are coming to steal my birthright, black spellwork thickens the air, and I’ve never been more terrified.There’s only one thing left to do—survive.PLEASE NOTE: The heroine in this story will end up with more than one love interest and will never choose between them. This is book one in a five book series and will end on a cliffhanger.

Witch's Three


Jewel Killian - 2020
    Jeez.Delilah's got more magic than anyone. Ever. So, naturally the government wants it, sending a team of three why-are-they-soooo-flippin'-hot guys after her. One of whom, just so happens to be her familiar. Her human familiar -- that hasn't happened in, well, ever. But the government isn't alone in wanting a piece of Del's power. Something else is after her. Something dark and twisted. Something which no one believes exists. How could it?Witch's Three is a medium-burn FMMM RH with a hunky unicorn shifter, a dead sexy seer, and a grumbly, broody gargoyle and Delilah will never, ever have to choose between them.

Between


Katie May - 2019
    The liars and the psychopaths.Everybody at the school is hiding behind a mask, including the professors. They say monsters roam the halls of this academy at night, and I think...I think they might be right.

Academy Obscura: The Flame Within


Cassia Briar - 2019
    A twisted magical college. Three sexy teachers.I didn't know magic existed…until I found my birth family after a life in foster care. They tell me there are rules, but I don’t believe them. Naturally, I break one of those precious rules on the night of a full moon, and am forced to enroll at Academy Obscura. But I don’t fit in. After all, I’m not a witch, vampire, fae, werewolf, or shifter. Am I?Worse, the penalty for messing up at the Academy? Death. My only chance of survival lies in the hands of three frustratingly hot teachers. Jaxon, a powerful but untrustworthy witch. Liam, a fae who avoids my flirtations. And Angel, the alpha werewolf who enthusiastically tears apart my enemies, but openly broods when I’m around.I am drawn to all of them. But, how can one woman have three men?Author’s Note: This is a steamy, medium burn, reverse harem paranormal romance featuring shifters, witches, and fae. It includes adult language, violence, and possibly triggering situations. Recommended for mature readers.

Magical Academy for Delinquents


Ann Denton - 2020
    No one but me. I’ve purposely gotten kicked out of three prestigious academies. It’s taken two and a half years. Finally, I’m about to get put into their reform program. And I’m thrilled. Not about the shit classes at this boarding school. Definitely not about the intense physical regimen. I’m excited because this academy is the perfect recruiting grounds for what I need: a force, a detonator, and a tock with loose morals and an affinity for breaking the rules. I need a powerful, heartless crew, because I’m about to pull off the magical heist of the century. Author's Note: This is a medium burn reverse harem romance intended for adult audiences.

To Catch a Bandit


Emma Dean - 2020
    Phantom. Raven.Emily is one of the most elite assassins in her flock. She is only one of two ravens granted the right to hunt solo at only twenty-three years old. Her first mission: find and take out an unknown target at a specified time and location.It should be easy enough, and yet...the last thing she expected was to see the male she'd danced with during the witches' Samhain Ball. For the first time in her professional career, Emily froze. It was the first time she couldn’t make the kill - not without answers.Little did she know she wasn’t the only assassin hired. There are three others to ensure all four raccoons shifters are dead. But before she can figure out what is going on, the raccoons take her through a portal and she lands in a different world.Will Emily follow them on their adventure, explore the feelings she still has for them, or will she follow through on her contract and kill the man she might be in love with?*This is a steamy reverse harem shifter romance with some MM. All paranormal books by Emma Dean exist in the same paranormal world - the Council of Paranormals.*

Homecoming Homicide


Albany Walker - 2021
    The once beautiful building had fallen into disrepair over the past few years.Belinda the new librarian was doing her best to clean it up, but a dead body wasn’t helping matters.Dad needs help to solve the murder, so that’s what I’m here to do, then get out of town before anyone even knows I’m backThe case should be easy for an MBI agent, even a newly minted one like me, but before I can check into the hotel my three reasons for leaving, corner in the lobby.My life just got a lot more complicated. Homecoming Homicide is a Cozy style Slow Burn RH with an adorkable Heroine and Three not so normal Fellas thrown into the mix.

Juniper's Sight


Jarica James - 2019
    A freak among freaks, you might say. Everyone around me has these amazing abilities; empathy, healing, telepathy. But I get to see beyond the veil. Lucky, right?Things start looking up for me when teams are determined. It seems like fate when my best friends Dexter and Sterling are assigned with me, along with the sweet and sexy twins, Asher and Alex.The RH Academy doesn’t normally assign co-ed teams, and I’m beginning to see why. One girl and four hot guys? What could go wrong?Our lives flip upside down when I bring everyone on an unsanctioned ghost hunt. Something evil is lying dormant in the underbelly of the dorm and we accidentally wake it up. Of course, it’s not just your average spirit, but one that’s out for blood. As the presence gets stronger, the veil weakens, magnifying the danger we’re facing.My team and I must come together to end his reign of terror before we lose not only our spot on the RH Forces but possibly our lives.The real question is when the shadows call, can I resist? Juniper's Sight is a RH Dark Academy Romance with mmfmm. It is intended for audiences 18+ and may have content some readers may find triggering. It was originally published as Into the Shadows, but has been fully rewritten, revised, and edited! Enjoy!

Knight Ascending


B.M. Clemton - 2021
    Trust no one. Is the singular phrase my mother had whispered to me when she abandoned me in a small hospital at the young age of eight. It was the only memory I could remember before I came to live with my Aunt and Uncles here in the largest wolf pack in North America.After graduated High School and having been accepted into one of the most prestigious Paranormal Universities in North America. Black Veil University. Everything is finally going as planned. Or so I thought before four insanely hot men crash their way into my life. Each with a unique connection to me, whether they want it or not. We are tied together.Lives are turned upside down, hearts are torn and shattered and those deep dark secrets that I have held hostage start to slip. But when the dark shadows of my past come knocking, I may need every little bit of help I can get. Knight Ascending is book 1 in the Black Veil University Series which DOES end on a cliffhanger. This is a university-aged, slow burn, slow build Paranormal RH romance which means there will be no choosing between love interest at the end of the story.*Trigger Warnings* This book has darker elements that readers should be aware of such as, strong language, PTSD from kidnapping, assault, and violence.

Magic Swap


Sadie Moss - 2019
    Sounds like the start of a joke, but nope...It's my life.After one too many kamikazes on my twenty-first birthday, I've made a few interesting discoveries.First of all... magic is real.Secondly... there's a whole supernatural dimension that exists parallel to ours.Thirdly... I've somehow gotten stuck in that dimension.FML.There are about a billion things wrong with this picture, including the fact that I don't actually have any magic. Everyone here thinks I do though. They also think I'm a witch named Roxie, the star student at Radcliffe Magical Academy.Ummm. Nope. Not me. Sorry.I don't know where the hell the real Roxie is, or how I'm supposed to get back home, but I'm determined to find out.Unfortunately, I keep getting distracted by three hot-as-hell warlocks I can't seem to avoid. Cross, a snarky bad boy who pushes all my buttons, Theo, an incorrigible flirt with a devastating accent, and Kasian, a teacher's assistant who's totally off limits.Even though I'm drawn to all three of them, I'm not sure I should trust them.Because if anybody finds out I don't belong here...I'm screwed.Magic Swap is the first book in the Hidden World Academy series, a fast-burn reverse harem story about a sassy human who's out of her depth and the three men who fall in love with her.

Werewolf Academy: Year One


Jayme Morse
    or die.After my parents die in a fire, the Darken pack comes to town. The werewolves are here for one thing: me.The Darken made a promise to keep me safe, and I need their protection more now than ever before. It turns out that my family has been keeping a secret from me my entire life: I'm a werewolf--a powerful one--and my life is in danger. The only place where I'll be safe is at Werewolf Academy, a boarding school for shifters like us. I feel an unnatural pull to Aiden, Colton, Rhys, and Theo, the cocky Alpha of the pack who wants to claim me as his own.The only problem? One hint: It's not that I'm failing Lunar Magic 101.I'm mated to all of them.Werewolf Academy is a YA paranormal reverse harem/paranormal academy romance. Recommended for ages 17+.

Protecting Hope


Briana Alisandra - 2020
    She was the only family I had. Scratch that. She was the only family I thought I had. It turns out my mother had a sister. Now I'm moving to a small town called Salem Point to live with her.There are a lot of interesting people here in Salem Point. My neighbor, Knight, is the sweetest guy I've ever met. I have an instant connection with him that I can't quite explain. Then there's Christian, the douche bag at school that can't seem to take his perfect eyes off of me. And to be fair, it's not a one-way street. And finally, there's Wyatt, the creepy guy that I only seem to find in dark corners following me around. Between mean girls and the most beautiful guys I've ever seen, my life is complicated.It turns out, it's about to get a lot more complicated. The people of Salem Point aren't what they seem. There are monsters in this town, and I might be one of them.A Reverse Harem Shifter/Vampire Paranormal Romance

Illusion of Escape


Lana Kole - 2018
    Focused on helping kids the system forgets, she is unaware of the powers she harbors deep in her soul. The intensity of her dreams waver between a nightmare and a true confidant. Imagine her surprise when she realizes her dreams might be more than they seem, she suddenly has crazy magic powers, and three strange men crash a too good to be true second date for help finding their long-lost friend. Loyalty means you don’t quit… Closer than brothers, Kaiser, Walker, Remington and Levi are not one without the others. Since Walker’s disappearance three years prior, they have not been the same. Driven to find their lost comrade, they are not above breaking any laws, be they magekynd or human. When a fluke encounter alerts them to Mori’s potential, they cannot ignore their instincts. Can they earn Mori’s trust after kidnapping her or will she walk away from the crazy world she’s been thrust into and the men who need her help? *87,953 word count full length first book in a series of three. *This is a Reverse Harem Paranormal Romance and is not suited for those under the age of 18.

The Queen's Nest


Merri Bright - 2021
    An innocent, intrepid woman with magical powers that can heal or kill thousands, she rose from the gutters of Rimholt at the command of her king to save her country and, um… take the king’s four best friends as her consorts.Can you blame her? Those generals knew exactly how to storm a girl’s castle.Her men have sworn to protect their queen with their lives, though assassins lurk in every shadow. Vali’s the real target, but when her enemies finally attack, her lovers are the ones dying.But Queen Vali isn’t afraid to fight back, and she’ll risk everything—even her life—to protect her mates.The Queen’s Nest is a 22,000-word novella that follows events in The King’s Omega. While books in the series can be read alone (no cliffhangers), it’s more fun if you read them in order. See Merri Bright's Amazon Author page for series order. All books in The Lost Lines Series feature heroines with multiple love interests, steamy scenes, and Happily Ever Afters for all. Content warnings are in the Author’s Note just inside the book—please read before deciding to buy.

Love is my Superpower


Luna Blake - 2021
    Lonely and isolated - but peaceful. I did all the things an Earth Witch does while trying to avoid the past and not think much about the future: Bake cookies, plant flowers, hang out with Cheetoe, my feline familiar. Drink too much beer and wine.And then, she showed up. My worst nightmare wrapped in black wings and red lipstick. The Succubus.And for some reason, she has it out for me and my town.After a thorough thrashing from her leaves me bloody and unconscious, I wake up in the cabin at the end of the lane, staring into the blue eyes of my savior.And his super hot roommate. And his other hot roommate - that hates me for some reason. Oh, and his other hot roommate,  who eats more chips than anyone I've ever known. Just me, four hot guys, and my snarky cat......and more than a few dark secrets.