Book picks similar to
Into the Shadows by Rowan Thalia


reverse-harem
dnf
rh
paranormal-romance

Dreaming Of You (Dreams #1)


Melissa Adams - 2021
     Girls start disappearing from her college campus, and her dreams become darker - more twisted than before. When life seems like it can't get any more complicated, the arrival of four hot football players who insert themselves into Selena's life. But how can she choose just one, when they're all so great? And with the danger her Mom and Grandma warned her about, college life just got even harder for Selena. Warning: this book has sexual content so it is intended for an audience aged 18+ ***WARNING: This book DOESN’T end on a cliffhanger but it is the first of a series of 3, so some situations will be resolved and developed in the next two books.

Heart of Magick


Trillian Black - 2019
     Crazy hot and totally mysterious; Jace, Bastian, Dorian and Ethan are the ones who run this town. My magick keeps drawing me to them, but whenever one of them touches me, my power glitches out of control.  After a centuries-long search, the guys believe my powers are a sign that they've found their mate. They say it’s the Pentamorous bond; an ancient spell that joins five souls for eternity. If I accept this fate, we’ll live happily ever after. Thing is, I don’t believe in fairy tales. NOTE: The Pentamorous Key series is a completed Reverse Harem Paranormal Romance trilogy. Medium/Fast burn, #whychoose, and extra steamy.

Visions


Elle Lincoln - 2021
    Not for food either. For a four-letter word that rhymes with lick.Don’t act all coy, we all know what I’m talking about, and I just so happen to have four very delicious men vying for my attention.My ex, Pim, who stole my heart and my fear when he chose to become a shade rather than spend endless days worshipping my body.Greyson, who wants my heart and not just my lady taco. Well, if he isn’t going to give it up, then he needs to stop walking around in that fireman gear because… damn.Oh, and Hades, who has that whole bad boy persona going for him, but he’s a secret teddy bear at heart. I want to see if I can bring the God of the Underworld to his knees.Then there is Apollo, who is a rage monster hell-bent on making me his when I want to make him mine instead.It’s a shame my world went crazy and weird things keep happening all around me, because I definitely have better things to do. Or rather men.Who do I have to kill for a few moments of peace so I, Nessa, can claim these creatures as mine?VISIONS is book 1 of 4 in a slow burn reverse harem romance with so much sexual tension, it’ll leave you panting for more.Oh... And a Cliffhanger. If you're new here, sorry not sorry. If you aren't, you totally knew this was coming.

Home


Lyla Oweds - 2019
     That's how I've lived my whole life being able to see spirits. Pretending to be normal begins to pay off though. Despite my weirdness, things are finally getting better. Somehow, I found a home with parents and a new life. No one needs to know. But then I meet Finn. He's in my class, and is slowly being killed by a demon. No one else seems to notice. At first, I try to ignore it too, but then Finn Abernathy starts following me everywhere. It's really annoying, but... I feel bad. He's dying in front of me and I can't just let it kill him. That would make me the worst person in the world. There's no other way but for me to stop it. I only hope I know what I'm doing. This book might contain trigger warnings.

Save Me (Shifting Allegiance, #1)


Imani L. Hawkins - 2020
    . . from my family. That’s what happens when your father is a murderous asshole. My mother was a mobster's daughter until he killed her and my grandfather, before pinning their deaths on me. Alone in a small town away from everyone I've ever known, I don’t exactly have many friends. Until I met them. Three devastatingly sexy werewolves caught me stealing from their store And instead of killing me, took me in. Now my brother’s caught in my father’s crosshairs, and he’s the only family I care about. I have to go back. Take down the club.Take down my father. And save my brother. But I’m not doing it alone.

Three for a Witch


Lucy Auburn - 2018
     I was supposed to cry my broken heart away. Instead I did a spell to draw three men to me: Orlando, Roman, and Jack. There were my best friends when we were kids. Then something more when we were all fourteen. And I still long for them. But things have changed since we were fourteen. There are cracks and missing pieces. And somewhere out there in the woods, a darkness lurks… a darkness coming for us all. I just hope we can reunite in time to face it, or we might not live to see tomorrow. Three for a Witch is a complete, standalone novel with no cliffhangers in sight.

Valkyrie's Harem


Angel Lawson - 2019
    Not for Morgan and the Raven Guard, not for the six, sexy, Immortals freed from servitude and living in the Nead's basement.And especially not me, a Valkyrie, stricken with grief and loss.My best friend, Morgan and her husbands, are determined to move on, build a family, and live in peace, but the fates aren't satisfied. There's a new battle on the horizon and the gods demand the warrior's fight.Lucky for the Guardians there’s more than one warrior with a death wish in this house.The Legion of Immortals can’t pass up a good fight, even if they’re not happy to have me along, and typically, nothing goes as planned when we cross realms.Roles are reversed. Boundaries are crossed. Relationships are formed. Redemption is sought.Can any of us find what we need? And what if what we need is one another?The Valkyrie's Harem is a follow-up series to The Raven Queen's Harem, Angel Lawson's best selling reverse harem romance.

The Hidden Cure (Silver Moon, #1)


Kat Blak - 2020
    No amazing powers, not even earth magic. Until the day she stumbles into four not so normal guys who seem to think she needs protecting and they're ones to do it. And to think it all started with a concert. Will the guys keep her hidden or will the ones after her win? This is a reverse harem intended for ages 18+ Please be advised there are a few trigger warnings to take into account: abuse almost non-consent scenes

Ghosted by You


Tiegan Clyne - 2020
    The third season is about to begin filming, and the producers want to up the ante. The three macho, pseudoscience brosephs - Quinn, Tyler and Brent - are about to be joined by a very female psychic, Emma Ray.The team is instantly resentful of her presence on their show, and lead investigator Quinn has made it clear that he doesn't believe in psychics. They're going to give Emma the hardest of hard times until they can expose her as a phony.They're going to learn that Emma is the real deal, and that it's not always wise to bully a psychic when you don't know how many ghosts are in her posse...or exactly what you’ll be facing in the next haunted house."Ghosted by You" is a medium-burn Reverse Harem paranormal ghost-hunting adventure. Not suitable for readers under 18 years of age.

Merlyn Academy Book One


Sophia Stone - 2020
     An orphan, dumped into the foster care system and bullied throughout school, I tried to keep my head down until I was old enough to leave. That was the plan. At least it was, until I found out I was from one of the most prestigious magical families, the Castles, and I was to attend Merlyn Academy for Witches and Wizards. As a Castle, I am able to master all four magical elements. This makes me exceptional. As a Castle, I am also part of a notorious family who died in pursuit of power. This makes me dangerous. While everyone else treats me with suspicion, it is only my roommate, Elenore, the guy who saved me from some bullies, Harry, and the four Knight brothers, who are brave enough to befriend me. I only have three goals while at the academy; to find out who I am, learn to control my powers and to not fall in love with five guys. What could possibly go wrong? Book Two: Pre-order is now live!

Mutant Academy


Yumoyori Wilson - 2019
    Tara’s a Mutant, superior in strength, psychic ability, intelligence, and skill. Now she’s been living with other captured mutants within the walls of The Fundamental Society. The Society’s mission? Gather the survivors, those Mutants that didn’t die in captivity, and use them as lab rats to further Human ingenuity. Tara assumes this is her life now, but a chance mistake leads to her escape. She tastes freedom, for precious, short minutes...and comes across a group of sexy, stern guys who happen to be Mutants – seconds before her electro-shock wristlet turns back on. She wakes up somewhere strange, but wonderful: Mutant Academy, a place where Mutants live and learn in harmony. It’s competitive, but it’s an opportunity that will allow her to leave her lab years in the past…forever. This is Tara’s first real chance at freedom, surrounded by those she can trust, grow, and love as a woman, rather than a living experiment. At least, it’s supposed to be. Even within the cloistered walls of Mutant Academy, not everything is as safe and sound as it seems. In a twisted game of cat-and-mouse, Tara must figure out who the real predator is — otherwise she’ll forever be the lab rat.

The Last Pendragon


Aurora Dawn - 2018
    A kingdom that’s hers for the taking. And five warriors who will do anything to serve their queen. With a milestone birthday looming, newly single Carrie isn’t looking forward to the not so secret surprise party she has coming up, especially since her ex is going to be there with his brand new fiancé. But, when a strange chance encounter with the hottest man she’s ever seen sends her spiraling into a world she only thought existed in fables, Carrie soon finds that her life and identity is nothing like she imagined. Waking up in Camelot, Carrie finds herself surrounded by five-count ‘em five- smoking hot men, all sworn to stay by her side. They tell her that she’s the daughter of King Arthur and, as such, rightful queen of Camelot. But, with a dark queen already sitting on her throne, Carrie and her gaggle of supernatural protectors must embark on a journey that will bring them closer to death-and closer to her- then any of them ever imagined. With a loyal knight, a tattooed sorcerer, an immortal with a shocking connection to her, and a pair of twin dragon shifters who do everything together at her side, Carrie must find the strength to become the ruler she never thought she’d have to be…or lose everything in the process.A Reverse Harem Arthurian Fantasy

Veiled Wings


Mazzy J. March - 2021
    A little fact my parents failed to mention the entire time I was growing up. Then when it was time to apply to college, when all my friends were taking the SAT, I was informed that would not be necessary. I was a legacy to the Sciathian Academy, a private college so exclusive, I would find it in none of the brochures in my high school counselor’s office. No need to fill out an application or take the SAT. They apparently had their own tests… No financial aid forms because the families who sent their children there had funded the school with a legacy a long time ago. No need to do anything but show up and settle into my dorm.Pretty sweet. Also a little concerningEspecially when the private jet lands at an isolated airfield and I am ushered into a long, black car along with three other girls who all seem to have known one another since kindergarten and who are chattering away in another language. Gaelic, I think. And since I’d just left behind everyone and everything I knew, this did not bode well for the future. If everyone spoke this language, how would I even attend classes? Or pass a test?As if Fae Academy wasn’t hard enough, there are three guys that all want to date me.Wait, do fairies date? I think they have soul mates or something. Heck, I don’t even know what my powers are yet. I was never in the spotlight in high school, so why in the world am I the shining light here?Just when I decided to buckle down and study to be the best fairy I can, the whole world breaks open. For some reason the headmaster thinks I am the one who can intervene. I can’t even move a pebble or conjure up a rain cloud and they want me to save us?Dream on.I’m not the Fae for the job.

Saintly Virtues


S.A. Mackenzie - 2020
    Unfortunately for me, my life is about to change forever. Turns out that I am the prophesied Holy Warrior that will prevent Lilith (yeah, THE Lilith) from starting the apocalypse and taking over the world. Some higher being decrees that it’s up to me, and my oh so tasty seven mates, to take down Lilith before it's too late. Now not only will I have to find my scattered mates, battle a horde of demons, and fulfill the prophecy - these men have seriously awakened my libido, which is both fun and problematic.Needless to say, I am struggling to keep my head above water. Let's hope I can beat the apocalyptic clock and save the world. Should be easy, right? Saintly Virtues is the first in The Seven Sins and Saints trilogy. It is a full length Paranormal RH where the main character doesn’t have to choose. 18+ for sexual situations, swearing and mentions of abuse.

A Pinch of Sass


Chloe Gunter - 2019
    Patrick’s Day was something kids did to pass the time, but when she moves to Ireland she finds out how wrong she is. Who knew a pinch could change her life? Now she’s stuck with three sexy Leprechauns, three magical wishes, and one hell of a mystery to solve. But when someone fears Roz and her leprechauns are getting too close to a centuries old secret, they aren’t afraid to try to take them out. With a little luck, a lotta love, and laughs along the way, can they solve the mystery before she loses them forever?